Q. Pediatrician Daniel Alexander, MD (Brooklyn, NY),
subsequent to reading Melissa L. Block's article in the magazine Mothering
(July/August 2003) on Dr. Incao's fever recommendations, writes: "I have some
concerns... about your recommendations against fever suppression and for bowel
cleansing. When fever causes young children to refuse fluids, dehydration
becomes a problem. Also, the use of suppositories for bowel cleansing can lead
to further dehydration and electrolyte imbalances, leading to serious consequences."
A: This question raises an important point. The answer
requires us to look at the process of acute inflammatory illness more closely.
Every feverish illness proceeds in a rhythmical course with alternating cycles
in which fever takes hold of us, then lets go, takes hold, lets go, etc. This
is a primal biological process of contraction and expansion, like in-breathing
and out-breathing.
As fever takes hold, a child contracts and concentrates her
forces inward. She usually loses interest in play, food and drink and wants to
curl up under the covers. As the body temperature rises, the child perceives
its surroundings growing colder relative to its warming body and she starts to
feel chilled or even shiver.
As the "Father of Western Medicine" Hippocrates
rightly understood, this inward concentration of heat into the depths of the
body betokens a cooking, digesting and
ripening process which he named pepsis in Greek. During this
phase of inner contraction and cooking the child may be slightly dehydrated yet
instinctively refuses to drink or eat, because her bodily energy is fully
concentrated and engaged in the inner work of digesting of the illness. If a
child is induced to eat or drink during this phase of the illness, she often
vomits.
When the fever peaks or breaks and starts to come down, this
signals the expansion and relaxation phase of the illness process. The child
feels warm, may sweat and then, having perked up somewhat and thrown off the
blankets, may announce that she's thirsty and hungry, and may need to go to the
bathroom. This is the out-breathing phase, in which the waste products of the
previous cooking-digesting phase are eliminated through sweating and mucus
discharge as well as through the usual channels of bladder and bowels.
Hippocrates called this phase of the illness the catharsis,
meaning the active throwing off and release of poisons from the body. Having
detoxified somewhat, the child now feels better and may want to play and become
active. Often however, the catharsis is merely a hiatus and not the end of the
illness. After some hours the fever starts to rise again as the child, feeling
unwell, draws her energy inward for the work of further digesting the illness.
The inner work of digesting an inflammatory illness is much
easier for a child if its stomach and colon are relatively empty of food. A
child will often have vomiting and/or diarrhea at the very beginning of an
illness, and these will often abbreviate the illness or even prevent it
altogether.
The various complications of an inflammatory illness,
including dehydration, usually result from the incomplete digestion and/or the
inadequate catharsis of the illness, causing the child to become
"toxic."
Anti-inflammatory drugs like acetaminophen (Tylenol),
ibuprofen, and aspirin work by interrupting the cooking-digesting phase of the
inflammatory process, thus lowering the fever prematurely before the body is
ready and ripe for a cleansing catharsis. This explains why such
anti-inflammatory, fever suppressing drugs may increase the risk of toxic
complications in an inflammatory illness. Reye's syndrome from aspirin and the
invasive bacterial complications reported two years ago in New Zealand after
ibuprofen treatment of children with chicken pox are examples. I would argue
that dehydration is not caused by the fever itself, but by the inner toxicity
which results when fever is unable to do its job.
In 30 years of treating children's feverish, inflammatory
illnesses in the home, I have never recommended fever suppressants like Tylenol
for fevers below 106 degrees and I have never seen dehydration as a problem,
Nor have I ever seen dehydration result from judicious bowel cleansing with
suppositories or Milk of Magnesia in toddlers and children.
To be sure, infants are vulnerable to dehydration,
especially with repeated vomiting and diarrhea. I do not recommend Milk of
Magnesia for infants under one year old. Using a glycerin suppository in a
healthy feverish infant who hasn't had a bowel movement in the past 8 hours has
always proved helpful in making the infant more comfortable and less restless,
in my experience, and I believe it also helps the infant in getting over the
illness. When infants under six months old become ill for any reason, I always
recommend checking with your doctor.
PHILIP INCAO, M.D. maintains a medical practice in Denver,
Colorado.